Jump to content

1868 New York City mayoral special election

From Deep Politics Wiki


Full article adapted from Wikipedia revision 1368539655 by Wikipedia contributors. Text is available under CC BY-SA 4.0. Formatting has been adapted; article text and references are retained. Snapshot imported 2026-10-10.

<tbody> </tbody>
1868 New York City mayoral special election
← 1867
December 1, 1868
1870 →
<tbody> </tbody>
Nominee A. Oakey Hall Frederick A. Conkling
Party Democratic Republican
Alliance Tammany Hall
Popular vote 75,109 20,835
Percentage 78.28% 21.72%

Ward results
Hall: 50-60% 60-70% 70-80% 80-90% >90%

<tbody> </tbody>
Mayor before election

Thomas Coman
Democratic

Elected mayor

A. Oakey Hall
Democratic

<tbody> </tbody>

The 1868 New York City mayoral special election took place on December 1, 1868, to elect the Mayor of New York City.

A. Oakey Hall, the District Attorney backed by Tammany Hall, easily beat former Republican congressman Frederick A. Conkling at the general election.

Background

Following his election for governor on November 3, mayor John T. Hoffman resigned, creating a special election. Thomas Coman, the President of the Board of Aldermen, succeeded Hoffman as acting mayor.

It was essential to members of the "Tweed Ring" that its candidate, District Attorney A. Oakey Hall be elected. Oswald Ottendorfer was mentioned as a potential candidate at the convention, but he declined. Tammany Hall proceeded to nominate Hall by unanimous acclamation.[1]

A Democratic reform group opposed to Boss Tweed's pick of Hall for mayor asked former sheriff John Kelly to run for the office, who agreed, and after which he had himself nominated at the Masonic Hall "reform" convention. He was seen as the only major threat to Hall's election, having a major influence over the Irish vote.[2]

However, nine days after Kelly's nomination, he abruptly withdrew, citing poor health, and left for Europe. There were rumors that Kelly feared disclosure of irregularities during his time as sheriff, but no allegations surfaced. There was an attempt to nominate in Smith Ely Jr., a member of the New York County Board of Supervisors in his place, but this was unsuccessful.[3][4]

General election

Results

<tbody> </tbody>
1868 New York City Mayoral special Election[5][6]
Party Candidate Votes %
Democratic A. Oakey Hall 75,109 78.28%
Republican Frederick A. Conkling 20,835 21.72%
Total votes 95,944 100.00%

References

Bibliography